SVEUM TAKES AN UNINTENTIONAL WALK
In the midst of an exciting post season - will the Rays run the table? - the Milwaukee Brewers are searching for a new manager. No sooner was the ink dry on Doug Melvin's new contract extension did he hop the first flight to Phoenix and told Dale Sveum thanks but no thanks. Now six games is a ludicrously short time to evaluate a manager's performance, which means that Melvin (and owner Mark Attanasio) already has his mind made up even before the season was over.
Did Sveum get a fair shot? Of course not. Melvin's reason was that they want to go with a "high profile" manager with prior big league managing experience. So let's take a look at the supposed short list of candidates who fall into this category:
1. Davey Johnson - an intriguing choice. By far the most successful of those on the list, Johnson managed four teams (Mets, Reds, Orioles and Dodgers) over 13 + seasons while compiling an impressive .562 winning percentage. Six of those teams won over 90 games and four others won over 85. That's ten out of 13 full seasons with 85 or more wins. He called it quits in 2000 but recently resurfaced as this year's Olympic Team manager. Soon to be 66, one would wonder about his longevity. Also, can he relate to today's players, especially a young team like the Brewers? He would certainly bring a winning tradition to the dugout.
2. Willie Randolph - His highly visible mid-season firing won't help his cause even though he was the scapegoat for an underperforming Mets' team who for the second year in a row choked in the late season. In his three full years with the Mets he won 83, 97 and 88 games respectively. He is popular and players like playing for him. Still, the question will linger whether he has enough to guide another team expected to make the playoffs.
3. Mike Hargrove - Hargrove managed 15 ½ years with three teams, making him the most experienced candidate. His .503 winning percentage is hardly awe-inspiring especially when considering that he finished first five straight years with the Indians. He also walked out on his team in the middle of the season last year, what's to prevent him from doing so again?
4. Buck Showalter - the man with the Earl Weaver stature and demeanor but albeit not his success. He's managed a .516 winning percentage over 11 years including a 100 win season in Arizona's second season. Yet he's had just an average managing career. Like Randolph, he gets points for managing in the manic scene that is New York. By contrast, managing in Milwaukee would seem like a being at neighborhood block party.
5. Bob Brenly - Like Randolph, Brenly's resume shows 3 ½ years as a manager. The difference is that he owns two first place finishes and a World Series title. He also has an in-depth knowledge of the NL Central while spending the past 4 years as a Cubs TV analyst.
6. Grady Little - Little is a solid manager who got shafted first in Boston over one pitching change he made in the playoffs and in Los Angeles when Frank MacCourt also wanted a high profile manager and got Joe Torre. He is probably the most low profile candidate but arguably the most capable.
While I won't pick a winner, I will say that the next Brewers' manager will have even a tougher time getting the team back into the playoffs than it was getting there this year. Despite the oratory from both Melvin and Attanassio that they will make a "serious" run at keeping CC Sabathia the single biggest reason the team made the post-season, don't look at this as nothing more than an appeasement to the fans.
CC wants to stay in the National League, sure, but he has stated, despite his recent comments about considering a Milwaukee offer, that he would prefer a West Coast team. If the Dodgers get in the bidding, look for him to be in the Blue next year. (Hide the Dodger Dogs!)
They also need to replace Ben Sheets. Even though he is as fragile as a thin sheet of ice (no pun intended), he had a great year and will leave as the Brewers all-time leader in strikeouts.
There are other crucial decisions that need to be made, but that's another blog.
As for the upcoming Series - I like the Phillies makeup and team and am glad they are there. Against anyone else I'm cheering for them, but who can go against the Rays? I have been talking them up for the better part of two years and won't stop now. At the risk of putting the whammy on them, the Series will go the distance but the Rays will finish off an improbable year as unsuspecting World Champs.
Did Sveum get a fair shot? Of course not. Melvin's reason was that they want to go with a "high profile" manager with prior big league managing experience. So let's take a look at the supposed short list of candidates who fall into this category:
1. Davey Johnson - an intriguing choice. By far the most successful of those on the list, Johnson managed four teams (Mets, Reds, Orioles and Dodgers) over 13 + seasons while compiling an impressive .562 winning percentage. Six of those teams won over 90 games and four others won over 85. That's ten out of 13 full seasons with 85 or more wins. He called it quits in 2000 but recently resurfaced as this year's Olympic Team manager. Soon to be 66, one would wonder about his longevity. Also, can he relate to today's players, especially a young team like the Brewers? He would certainly bring a winning tradition to the dugout.
2. Willie Randolph - His highly visible mid-season firing won't help his cause even though he was the scapegoat for an underperforming Mets' team who for the second year in a row choked in the late season. In his three full years with the Mets he won 83, 97 and 88 games respectively. He is popular and players like playing for him. Still, the question will linger whether he has enough to guide another team expected to make the playoffs.
3. Mike Hargrove - Hargrove managed 15 ½ years with three teams, making him the most experienced candidate. His .503 winning percentage is hardly awe-inspiring especially when considering that he finished first five straight years with the Indians. He also walked out on his team in the middle of the season last year, what's to prevent him from doing so again?
4. Buck Showalter - the man with the Earl Weaver stature and demeanor but albeit not his success. He's managed a .516 winning percentage over 11 years including a 100 win season in Arizona's second season. Yet he's had just an average managing career. Like Randolph, he gets points for managing in the manic scene that is New York. By contrast, managing in Milwaukee would seem like a being at neighborhood block party.
5. Bob Brenly - Like Randolph, Brenly's resume shows 3 ½ years as a manager. The difference is that he owns two first place finishes and a World Series title. He also has an in-depth knowledge of the NL Central while spending the past 4 years as a Cubs TV analyst.
6. Grady Little - Little is a solid manager who got shafted first in Boston over one pitching change he made in the playoffs and in Los Angeles when Frank MacCourt also wanted a high profile manager and got Joe Torre. He is probably the most low profile candidate but arguably the most capable.
While I won't pick a winner, I will say that the next Brewers' manager will have even a tougher time getting the team back into the playoffs than it was getting there this year. Despite the oratory from both Melvin and Attanassio that they will make a "serious" run at keeping CC Sabathia the single biggest reason the team made the post-season, don't look at this as nothing more than an appeasement to the fans.
CC wants to stay in the National League, sure, but he has stated, despite his recent comments about considering a Milwaukee offer, that he would prefer a West Coast team. If the Dodgers get in the bidding, look for him to be in the Blue next year. (Hide the Dodger Dogs!)
They also need to replace Ben Sheets. Even though he is as fragile as a thin sheet of ice (no pun intended), he had a great year and will leave as the Brewers all-time leader in strikeouts.
There are other crucial decisions that need to be made, but that's another blog.
As for the upcoming Series - I like the Phillies makeup and team and am glad they are there. Against anyone else I'm cheering for them, but who can go against the Rays? I have been talking them up for the better part of two years and won't stop now. At the risk of putting the whammy on them, the Series will go the distance but the Rays will finish off an improbable year as unsuspecting World Champs.

